nzone said:horribilisfan8184 said:Heard there is a new study out of Israel showing natural immunity provides 6-7 times greater protection than vaccines against reinfection. If true, getting the virus is helping the less fortunate receive better protection than the vaccines. Lemu, who's the humanitarian now? And if true then natural immunity, not vaccines, is the quickest path to ending this pandemic. And if true, then all you no admittance vaxxers should be banned from WGS until after your break through infection is defeated by your immune system. Mark my words they will look back in history and conclude the political choices on masking and shutting down society, schools, and businesses, and putting faith in fairly rapid deteriorating vaccine immunity, and not letting the virus take its natural course through the human population extended the pandemic and lead to variant after variant. Only arrogant humans would believe 15 years of human research trial and mostly error would be superior to 3 billion years of evolutionary immune system trial and error. Oh the hubris of the experts.
Link please.
Here you go.
https://www.israelnationalnews.com/News/News.aspx/309762
While I provided the link, it doesn't mean I am in 100% agreeance. As all things, I would like to see more data, especially since Britain has questioned Israel's results over other items like vaccine effectiveness against the Delta variant. If you were wondering, Britain has socialized medicine like Israel and keeps good records as well.
This to me only speaks to the specificity of the vaccine vs natural immunity. The vaccine only provides the spike protein, whereas natural immunity provide protection against the spike plus the nucleocapsid (viral structure that encapsulates the virus information) Simply put, natural immunity vs the mRNA vaccines provides more targets (epitopes) and more importantly, those targets that aren't under mutational pressure like the spike protein...meaning natural immunity SHOULD be able to handle variants better. Of course, are you in good enough shape rhat you are alright with catching COVID?
Now with all that being said, the vaccines seems to be doing what they were supposed to do. Keep those most susceptible from developing a bad case that can kill them. Amazing how this information has been out there from the start, but if you even mention the vaccine is non sterilizing, you're labeled an asshole. How about we just be happy there are options.
In regards to natural immunity vs vaccine, studies are showing two different routes in regards to process. I don't have the science chops to say one is better, especially when all that should matter is someone living through, if infected.
Many of the studies you hear about are still in preprint, which means they are simply for people to read. They have not been peer reviewed. I'm a big believer in the peer review process. How else are you going to know if you made wrong assumptions and/or conclusions?
Lastly, if you are waiting for a more traditional vaccine (attenuated virus), I understand the Novavax vaccine is the first one out with old school style. Hopefully approved by end of year.