Being in high schools and watching the recruiting process play out gives me a perspective that some don't. Not saying that its better, but definitely more moderated that is for sure.
A few years back, I saw first hand what happens when a kid all the rage at camps gets ghosted by programs because his skill level didn't continue to expand after the end of his sophomore year. He was offered a ton scholarships by group of 5 and some power 5 schools in his junior year, didn't play much at all after he transferred schools as a junior, and those offers weren't there come his senior year. I know that isn't the norm, but this idea of carpet bombing offers isn't exactly limited to football as both basketball and softball have employed the practice. Schools want to get in on the ground floor with recruits, they don't necessarily build relationships with the kids they offer, many just see the offers thrown a kid and there is a sense very commonly that there is nothing hurt by extending an offer. There is a FOMO principle to recruiting and it does give the feel at times that many of these kids are just cattle at auction. Just because a school offered, doesn't mean there is an intent to extend that offer when it matters or any interest by the kid.
From a high school student-athlete perspective, the process from a human standpoint is slimy and unseemly at a lot of points with a crap ton of ulterior motives not just by college coaches but those in advisory roles for the player. Honesty isn't always best practice and there are a lot of shiny things thrown around. In the end I'd default to whatever got the kid into the school that was the best fit for him or her, regardless of level or affiliation. I'm a bit jaded about the process and seeing kids shit on somewhat frequently doesn't help my perspective of the how the process plays out.
Bobby and even Stitt employed the policy that they were going to recruit kids in a tactical manner, and I think the proof is in the pudding. Montana has probably the deepest pool of talent we've had in a decade, replete with kids that are FBS caliber, and it has been the laser-sharp recruiting process of both Freshmen and transfers that have netted those gains. Lucas Johnson isn't here because Montana had an open position alone, but rather that Bobby had a relationship that brought him here. I think Bobby knows for the most part what he's getting in players and he's achieving that a bit differently than most. That doesn't make Bobby or his staff candidates for sainthood, but rather what he's doing is working because he's got a rather great track record at identifying talent and
getting them in the door and getting the most out of them.