kemajic said:
hoopmaster111 said:
As someone who has seen both QBs - Kemp and Forcier in person - Kemp is better suited to run QB position for the Spread Option than Forcier. Forcier ended up at Michigan the same way his brothers ended up at UCLA, etc - great marketing by the parents, playing at schools and in leagues were competition was suspect and stats could be easily racked up, and paying the Scout.com and Rival.com memberships which help with marketing making them look very attractive.
Kemp is bigger, stronger and faster than Forcier. Forcier is looking at possibly being the #3 guy on the Michigan roster next season because he is getting beat out by guys that have the same skill set Kemp has. He would be the #3 guy behing JJ and Kemp at UM IMO. Both QBs at UM are better. Hopefully we'll get a real chance to see what Kemp can do in a spread option offense. That will depend on whether or not the coaches are willing to open up the competition. If Forcier comes to UM and the competition is open - he would be the #3 guy at UM as well.
As another poster stated, this is the dumbest post of the year; you need to stay with hoops. Forcier had the #1 rating for accuracy by scouts coming out of HS in San Diego. Kemp's passing is so suspect, that the coaching staff has no confidence and converted him to a RB, where he is likely to stay. A spread QB still has to be able to throw the ball. Forcier's highlights also show excellent speed and running ability. In his true freshman year at Michigan, he started out impressively, but wore down as the BCS season progressed. He is small and was getting beat up. Robinson could be an All-American before he's through. Forcier backed him up this year in a quality fashion. His slight frame might be better served in FCS. He would tear up FCS, think Drew Brees.
Since he hasn't redshirted, he also has the option of taking a year off, building up his body and maturing, and moving on to another FBS team where he would have a better shot at starting and staying healthy.
Believe what you want Kem. Kemp has not had the chance to prove whether his passing is suspect or not so that in itself is a BS comment. I really don't know you, and you don't know me so perhaps you should take some time to get to know a little something about someone before you comment on what their football or basketball knowledge is.
I have seen what both Kemp and Forcier did in high school first hand in person. I can tell you hands down Kemp is the better athlete. Kemp was an all-conference guy in Football, Basketball and Track - that speaks to his athleticism. Really, Kemp can play ANY position but has the heart to be the best QB you'd ever see if he was given a chance - think Michael Vick. And he can take a hit - something you'd hope someone with a 'slighter' can take without being knocked out of a game which a few 'FCS' defenders have done to our QBs on more than one occassion who had at least 20lbs more on their frame than Forcier.
I believe ReMax posted several times on his reports on practices he was attending in both the Spring and Fall that Kemp's passing looked good. This can be seen in his senior highlight clips - which right now because of his lack of chances is the only real thing you have to go on show his passing, running, and athletic abilities in general in a game - that is if you have even taken a moment to look at them. If you haven't, here they are once again for your convenience:
As far as Kemp goes I am not sure what you are basing your comments on. Stats? Pecentage completion? Many times they are a flawed way to look at players. If a percentage of completion looks low - perhaps the QB was always under the gun and had to throw the ball away a lot - check for Ints - if they are low then that was probably the case. As we all know you gotta have a line and WRs that catch the ball in order to be fully effective which is why film or watching a kid in person is a better tool for determining exactly what you got in an athlete.
Forcier cannot be the starting QB at Michigan for the plain and simple fact that he is being beat out by a better athlete. I suspect that the guy that beat out Forcier wasn't rated as high as Forcier coming out of high school. If Scout's ratings are accurate Forcier should be starting and should not be looking to drop down.
You do know that most recruits pay to be on those sites (Scout & Rivals) unless they perform at the top levels at the combines like the one Nike runs in the spring and summer. If they don't participate in the combines or don't pay to be on those sites they don't get featured or marketed. The kids who pay are paying for marketing. Forcier was smart and did that and then some more marketing of his own. Additionally, kids like Kemp and Sambrano who run track and who get to their League, CIF Section and State Championships have to forego those combines because they are always held on a Track and Field Championship weekends.
What I don't understand is why the hell you would not want to put one of your best athletes at QB. Kemp is going into his Junior year next season and has four years (including his redshirt season) of experience as a college athlete. That's four years of physical development not to mention one year under his belt in this current offensive system that is suited to his style. He has a very strong arm, and with the speed and hands we have at WR in Moutra and Sambrano - Kemp would put some air under those passes and those guys could run underneath the ball for TDs instead having to stop and wait for it and get tackled short of the GL. But hey, what the hell do I know.